Constructive criticism of work by others is an essential aspect of scientific discovery. Here we show criticisms of our work as raised by others and our criticism of work done by others.

Comments by others on work at Sheffield

 

paper

 

paper

 

Our comments on work by others

 

  • Kakitsuba N. Comfortable Indoor Lighting Conditions Evaluated from Psychological and Physiological Responses.) Leukos, 2016; 12(3); 173-177
paper

Original article

paper

Criticism

paper

Response

  • Peña-García A, Hurtado A, Aguilar-Luzón MC. 2015. Impact of public lighting on pedestrians’ perception of safety and well-being. Safety Science, 78; 142-148.
paper

Original article

paper

Criticism

paper

Response

  • Kostic M, Djokic L, Pojatar D, Strbac-Hadzibegovic N. Technical and economic analysis of road lighting solutions based on mesopic vision. Building and Environment 2009; 44; 2006-2007
paper

Original article

paper

Criticism

  •  
  • Van Creveld K. An investigation into the relationship between luminance and brightness of strongly chromatic light sources. Lighting Research and Technology 1999; 31(3): 117-122.
paper

Original article

paper

Criticism and Response